Before the Contract: Does Your Club Understand Female Athletes?
Why menstrual-cycle competence should be a pre-qualification requirement for clubs recruiting professional female footballers.
Professional football clubs invest considerable resources in identifying, recruiting, and developing players. Technical ability, tactical suitability, physical performance, injury history, and projected development are routinely assessed before recruitment decisions are made. Yet an equally important question receives considerably less attention: does the club adequately understand the physiological characteristics of the female athletes it intends to employ?
For an agent representing professional female footballers, understanding how a prospective club manages its players throughout the menstrual cycle should be a fundamental qualification requirement. Before discussing salaries, playing opportunities, facilities, or long-term development, an agent should establish whether the organisation possesses the medical expertise, operational processes, and decision-making capability necessary to manage female athletes appropriately. This is not a question of preferential treatment or additional welfare provisions. It concerns the fundamental competence of an organisation responsible for an athlete’s health, performance, availability, and professional career.
Understanding the Entire Cycle
The menstrual cycle is not simply menstruation. It encompasses the follicular phase, ovulation, and luteal phase, with hormonal changes occurring throughout the process. Individual cycles vary in duration, and physiological responses can differ significantly between players. These variations may coincide with changes in symptoms, fatigue, perceived exertion, recovery, and other factors relevant to athletic performance.
The distinction matters because injury occurrence and physical performance cannot be properly evaluated by considering menstruation in isolation. A club must understand the entire cycle, recognise that individual responses vary, and investigate whether particular periods are associated with changes in physical condition, recovery, or injury occurrence. Understanding those relationships requires longitudinal information rather than general assumptions about female athletes.
A 2024 study published in Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise examined 593 menstrual cycles and 74 injuries involving 26 professional female footballers across three seasons. Researchers found muscle-injury incidence approximately five times higher during the early luteal phase and six times higher during the premenstrual phase compared with menstruation. Non-contact injury incidence was also significantly higher during the premenstrual phase, demonstrating differences in injury patterns across the observed cycle phases.
Further evidence emerged from a four-season observational study published in Frontiers in Sports and Active Living in December 2025. Researchers examined 852 menstrual cycles and 80 injuries among 33 elite female footballers. Although overall injury incidence did not differ significantly between menstrual bleeding and non-bleeding days, injury burden during menstruation was substantially higher, at 684 days lost per 1,000 hours of exposure compared with 206 during non-bleeding periods. Unlike the earlier study, this research did not distinguish the remaining menstrual-cycle phases, limiting the conclusions that could be drawn about when injuries occurred throughout the entire cycle.
These studies do not establish universal injury-risk periods applicable to every female footballer, nor do they demonstrate that hormonal fluctuations independently caused the observed injuries. They do, however, provide measurable evidence of relationships between menstrual-cycle timing and injury outcomes in professional football. For organisations responsible for managing female athletes, those findings warrant serious consideration alongside their own player-specific data.
Why QQSI Evaluates Four Consecutive Weeks
QQSI’s scouting methodology requires four consecutive weeks of performance observation within a one-month assessment period. This is not menstrual-cycle tracking, and we do not require knowledge of a player’s individual cycle to conduct the assessment. Instead, the methodology recognises that an athlete’s capabilities and contributions may vary from week to week, and that isolated performances provide an inadequate basis for evaluating her overall capabilities.
Our analysts manually assess players across four consecutive weeks, examining physical, technical, tactical, mental, and other observable contributions. Performance is evaluated week by week, allowing us to identify variations in capability, consistency, effectiveness, and behaviour under different conditions. Those assessments are subsequently consolidated into an aggregate score representing the player’s performance across the observation period rather than a single match or selected collection of performances.
We recognise that some weeks may be stronger than others and that different capabilities may fluctuate independently. Physical output might decline while tactical discipline, communication, positioning, or leadership remain consistent. Similarly, changes in confidence, concentration, decision-making, or relationships with teammates may influence overall performance without appearing clearly in conventional statistical reporting.
The purpose is to establish what the player demonstrates across the month, identify when and where capabilities change, and incorporate those observations into a more representative evaluation. We do not automatically attribute variations to the menstrual cycle, particularly when that information is unavailable. Four weeks also do not necessarily correspond to one complete biological cycle, nor can a single month establish a recurring physiological pattern. The process provides an observation-based performance assessment, not a medical diagnosis.
Recruitment and player management present different circumstances. A prospective club may already possess detailed longitudinal information about its existing players, while individual information about a recruit may become available through appropriately authorised medical disclosures. Consequently, the club may have opportunities to understand physiological factors that an external scouting organisation cannot independently establish. The question is whether the club possesses the expertise and systems to use that information responsibly.
Seven Questions Every Agent Should Ask
For an agent considering placing a female footballer with a professional club, we would establish seven fundamental requirements before proceeding to a more comprehensive assessment.
- Does the club demonstrate a working understanding of the complete menstrual cycle, including the follicular phase, ovulation, and luteal phase, and how physiological changes may affect individual performance, recovery, and injury considerations?
- Does the club maintain a voluntary, confidential system for monitoring individual menstrual cycles, associated symptoms, recovery patterns, and relevant physiological information over time?
- Do the club’s medical, sports science, and performance personnel possess demonstrable qualifications and specialist expertise in female physiology, menstrual health, and associated athletic performance considerations?
- How does the club incorporate relevant individual physiological information into training-load management, conditioning, recovery, nutrition, rehabilitation, and match preparation, and who is responsible for making those decisions?
- Can the club demonstrate an understanding of how injury occurrence, injury type, and injury severity vary across menstrual-cycle phases within its own playing population, and how it evaluates individual patterns against broader research findings?
- What procedures exist to identify menstrual irregularities, significant symptoms, low energy availability, and other health concerns, and how does the club ensure that players can seek medical assistance without compromising confidentiality, selection, or contractual standing?
- Can the club provide documented examples of how menstrual-cycle information has informed player-management decisions, medical interventions, or training adjustments, including how the effectiveness of those decisions was subsequently evaluated?
These questions are not designed to determine whether a club possesses a particular application, produces medical reports, or employs someone with a relevant job title. They establish whether the organisation understands the physiological factors affecting its athletes and has integrated that knowledge into operational decisions. The distinction between possessing information and acting effectively upon it is fundamental.
An organisation may collect extensive data while failing to identify patterns, communicate findings, or adjust its management practices. Medical personnel may recognise a developing concern without their recommendations influencing training or selection decisions. A club may even acknowledge increased vulnerability during particular periods while lacking the processes necessary to respond appropriately. Each represents a potential capability gap with consequences extending beyond the individual medical issue.
When Capability Gaps Become Operational Failures
A player’s availability depends on multiple interconnected functions, including medical assessment, physical conditioning, training management, rehabilitation, coaching decisions, and communication. Weakness within one function can affect several others, particularly where relevant information fails to reach the personnel responsible for making decisions.
Consider a player who repeatedly experiences significant fatigue, reduced recovery, or particular physical symptoms during certain portions of her cycle. If those patterns are documented but not adequately evaluated, training demands may remain unchanged despite relevant medical concerns. Where the athlete subsequently suffers an injury, the immediate consequence is lost availability, but the effects can extend into rehabilitation, physical conditioning, confidence, squad selection, and contractual development. The injury itself cannot automatically be attributed to menstrual physiology, but the organisation’s failure to examine available warning indicators remains an identifiable management deficiency.
This reflects a broader principle within QQSI’s methodology: capabilities must be evaluated according to their operational effectiveness, not merely their existence. A club employing qualified personnel and collecting appropriate information must also demonstrate that its processes work together, that relevant findings influence decisions, and that the consequences of those decisions are assessed.
There is also an important difference between an unavoidable injury and a potentially manageable risk that was never properly investigated. No club can eliminate injuries, nor does existing research provide sufficient evidence to predict individual injuries solely from menstrual-cycle timing. Nevertheless, uncertainty about the precise mechanisms does not justify ignoring documented patterns, particularly when clubs possess individual records extending across multiple seasons.
Qualification Before Recruitment
An agent’s responsibility does not end with identifying clubs willing to offer a contract. The suitability of an organisation must also be examined in relation to its ability to manage the player throughout her employment. A financially attractive offer, modern facilities, or a prominent coaching appointment does not automatically establish that a club possesses the necessary understanding of female physiology.
The seven questions therefore represent a pre-qualification standard rather than a comprehensive club assessment. A club demonstrating adequate understanding, expertise, monitoring, intervention procedures, and operational effectiveness can progress to further consideration. An organisation unable to explain how it manages these fundamental responsibilities presents a capability gap that should be resolved before recruitment discussions advance.
This is where QQSI’s scouting and organisational assessment methodologies intersect without becoming identical. In scouting, we manually evaluate a player’s week-to-week capabilities over four consecutive weeks and consolidate those observations into an aggregate assessment, recognising that performance is neither constant nor adequately represented by isolated matches. In club qualification, we examine whether an organisation understands the individual physiological factors influencing its players and possesses the capability to incorporate that understanding into ongoing management decisions.
Both approaches reject the assumption that a single performance, a generic profile, or the presence of a particular resource is sufficient evidence of capability. They require observation, context, evaluation, and an understanding of the relationships influencing outcomes.
Professional women’s football has made considerable progress in recruitment, sports science, performance analysis, and commercial development. The management of female physiology must be subject to comparable professional standards. Clubs cannot reasonably claim comprehensive player-development capabilities while remaining unable to demonstrate how they understand and manage a fundamental aspect of the athletes under their care.
For an agent responsible for representing female footballers, these seven questions should come before the contract. If a club cannot demonstrate the minimum competence required to understand and manage female athletes appropriately, its suitability as a prospective destination remains unestablished.
Research References
Barlow, A., Blodgett, J. M., Williams, S., Pedlar, C. R., & Bruinvels, G. (2024). Injury Incidence, Severity, and Type Across the Menstrual Cycle in Female Footballers: A Prospective Three Season Cohort Study. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 56(6), 1151–1158. https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0000000000003391
Ferrer, E., Keay, N., Balagué-Dobón, L., Cáceres, A., Jarrin, P., Rodas, G., & González, J. R. (2025). Menstruation and injury occurrence; a four season observational study in elite female football players. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living, 7, 1665482. https://doi.org/10.3389/fspor.2025.1665482
Disclaimer
This publication provides independent, apolitical analysis of historical developments, current events, geopolitics, national security, and strategic challenges. We maintain strict political neutrality, aligning with neither the left nor the right. Examining or criticizing political actors, institutions, or policies does not constitute political advocacy, opposition, or endorsement.
Our assessments are grounded in historical facts, available evidence, established analytical methodologies, and evaluations of probability, consequence, and uncertainty. Hypothetical scenarios are illustrative and do not imply actual or planned events, intentions, or operations.
Our purpose is to identify, define, and understand problems—not to prescribe solutions or advocate outcomes. Conclusions reflect the available evidence, not political preferences. Decisions and actions remain the responsibility of others.